Part of our hesitation comes from a broader question about what certification actually communicates.
Certifications can be extremely valuable. In areas such as information security, quality management or technical competence, independently demonstrating that you comply with a recognised standard can provide customers with important assurances.
Responsible business is more difficult to reduce to a certification.
One of the most prominent examples of this debate came when Nespresso achieved B Corp certification in 2022. Its admission attracted criticism from within the B Corp community itself, with more than 30 B Corps and other organisations signing an open letter objecting to the decision. Critics raised concerns about Nespresso's supply chain and questioned whether the certification process was sufficiently demanding of large multinational businesses.
Nespresso, for its part, has invested substantially in areas such as recycling, sustainable coffee sourcing and environmental initiatives, and B Lab stood behind its decision to certify the company. We're not suggesting that Ostratto is in a position to decide whether Nespresso should or shouldn't qualify.
The controversy does, however, demonstrate the limitations of reducing something as complicated as responsible business to a single badge.
Under the B Corp framework used at the time, companies could achieve the required overall score while performing more strongly in some areas than others. That meant two businesses with very different operations, impacts and individual category scores could ultimately display the same B Corp certification.
Importantly, B Lab has recognised some of these concerns and has since overhauled its standards. Its newer framework requires businesses to meet requirements across seven impact areas rather than relying on an aggregate score where stronger performance in one area could compensate for weaker performance elsewhere.
We think that's a positive development, and it's important to acknowledge it.
There have also been examples showing that B Corp isn't simply a badge awarded indefinitely. BrewDog, for example, lost its B Corp certification in 2022 after B Lab investigated concerns surrounding the company and requested additional measures that BrewDog ultimately did not complete.
So our position isn't that B Corp has no standards or accountability. Clearly it does, and those standards continue to evolve.
Our point is that no certification can give customers the complete picture of a business.